This post aims to show you how you can use a Yubico YubiKey NEO hardware-based two-factor authentication device to improve authentication and logins to OSX and other software and services.

Background

Although I am a developer I do like security related topics and I try and do as much as I can to secure my systems and applications. Reading the Multi-Factor Authentication Wikipedia page has all the details on Multi-Factor authentication.

I have been a big fan of 1Password to generate strong and unique passwords for separate accounts for a while now. Read my guide on upgrading from a standalone 1Password licence to a 1Password subscription. I love generating unique and complex passwords with 1Password.

But what happens if someone gets access to my 1password vault? Yubico has a catalogue of support services that I can use Yubikeys with to have, 1password is one supported service 🙂

I want to add Yubico protections with these services.

• macOS Logins (DONE)
• macOS Screensavers (DONE)
• 1Password (DONE)
• Dropbox (DONE)
• Twitter (DONE)
• Google (DONE)
• Google GSuite (DONE, WAITING TO VERIFY)
• Google GMail (DONE)
• Google Analytics and AdSense (DONE)
• Github (DONE)
• Thunderbird Email (DONE)
• Debian servers in the cloud (SSH) (DONE)
• Ubuntu servers in the cloud (SSH) (DONE)
• Securing WordPress (DONE)

Etc

Final Warning

Do not attempt to activate Two Factor Authentication on a system unless you…

• A) Have backups of your data
• B) Have backup methods of getting into your account(s)

Murphy’s Law: “Anything that can go wrong will go wrong”

You never know when a Two Factor Authentication Key may die or an Authenticator app or a Mac/PC may stop working so always have a backup method just in case.

General

General Yubico YubiKey Setup guides https://www.yubico.com/setup/

Buying a Yubico YubiKey

International visitors can buy a YubiKey from the official store here. Australian readers can buy a key locally here. I grabbed 2x YubiKey YubiKey Neo 4 (with NFC) for $50 USD (about $75 AUD) each.

This blog post will aim to show how you can set up a primary key and backup key for use on macOS and other apps to add hardware-based two-factor authentication to logins.

Authenticator Apps

You can use Google Authenticator, Yubico Authenticator or freeOTP from https://freeotp.github.io

Plugging the YubiKey into macOS Mojave

First I read this guide: https://www.yubico.com/works-with-yubikey/catalog/macos/

1) I plugged in my Yubico Neo key into my USB slot.
2) I closed the Keyboard setup window that appeared (I guess the YubiKey is a kind of a keyboard to allow inserting of challenge-response character streams into apps and websites).

3) I followed the basic troubleshooting page and confirmed that the key was being detected (yes it was.)

4) I followed this guide to test U2F functionality and this guide to test OTP functionality. Web pages and Google Chome can talk to the plugged-in YubiKey(s).

I was prompted to register a UTF deice (and create an account)

I was prompted to (insert) and touch my Yubico key.

Google Chome asked for some permissions first.

FYI: Chrome 67 is recommended to securely allow the reading of UbiKey’s from web pages. Only allow sites you trust access to your USB devices and use a modern browser.

Success, Chrome could now see my YubiKey and my device was now verified.

Technical data is available to let you know what is going on in the background. I am not going to break down how this works but Yubico has in-depth whitepapers and documentation if you are interested.

Nice

Configuring OSX

I logged into my Mac with the account that I was going to secure.

I performed a complete time machine backup before proceeding. If you lock yourself out you will need to restore OSX from a Time Machine backup.

I Read the “Using Yubico Pluggable Authentication Module (PAM) with Challenge-Response” login guide: https://www.yubico.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/yubico_YubiKeyMacLoginGuide_en.pdf

I downloaded the Download the YubiKey Manager

I downloaded the yubikey-manager from here so I could configure the keys to use “HMAC-SHA1 Challenge-Response”.

Oops, I downloaded the wrong tool, good to know this one exists though.

I will update what this tool does in future (update firmware?)

I Downloaded the Yubikey Personalization Tool

I went back to the Yubico download page and downloaded the Personalization tool.

Many options are available here.

It’s time to configure a primary and backup (duplicate YubiKey) for use with macOS etc.

Enable Challenge-Response

I opened the YubiKey Personalization Tool, Inserted my primary key, clicked the Settings tab, and in the Logging Settings group, selected Log configuration output and Yubico format.

I then clicked on the Challenge Response Tab, clicked the HMAC-SHA1 button, selected Configuration Slot 2, ticked “Program Multiple YubiKeys“, changed the “Parameter Generation Scheme = Same for all Keys“, Selected “Fixed 64 byte input” under “HMAC-SHA1 Parameters” and generated a new key (wrote it down).

Under “Configuration Protection” then I selected Enable Protection” I then visited here and generated a 6 digit string to convert to hex array (with spaces (e.g: “70 61 73 73 77 64”)).

Warning: If you set an access code and later forget it, you cannot make any programming changes to this YubiKey. You would need to buy another YubiKey.

I clicked on Write Configuration

If you chose Configuration Slot 1 you will receive a warning about not saving over Configuration Slot 1 due to Yubico VIP/Symantec, I personally do not trust Symantec or the https://vip.symantec.com/ service due to Symantec issuing non-compliant certificates for use on websites. Yubico allows you to swap configuration slots if want to keep the configuration data.

On the output of the first write, I was prompted to save a file. I saved this to “secretkey.csv” onto the Desktop.

When the write to my primary key was successful, I ejected it then inserted my backup key and wrote the same configuration data to it too (on Configuration Slot 2).

Testing the HMAX-SHA1 Challenge

I open the YubiKey Personalization Tool, then click the Tools tab and click Challenge Response. Choose Configuration Slot 2, I selected HMAC-SHA1. I typed a sample input challenge (e.g “hello world”) and clicked Perform.

I noticed the Yubico key touch panel was flashing. I pressed the button, then a response appeared below the input textbox. I copied this response text then insert your second key and perform the same test so I could compare the responses (they should be the same). They were.

If the responses don’t match rewrite the configuration to your primary and secondary keys and ensure the same key and secret was used for both keys.

FYI: I rewrote configuration a few times until I got it right.

Installing the Pluggable Authentication Module (PAM) on macOS

I re-read the Mac login guide here as I don’t want to lock myself out of my Mac.

I opened the Yubico Software Download page here and clicked Computer Login Tools and downloaded the PAM for Mac.

I installed the PAM package and verified the package installation with this command.

ls -al /usr/local/lib/security

Output:

Text Output:

> drwxr-xr-x 3 root wheel 96 9 Oct 10:29 .

> drwxrwxr-x 74 simon admin 2368 9 Oct 10:29 ..

> -rwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 143172 20 Apr 21:13 pam_yubico.so

Backup macOS

Again I ensured my Mac was backed up with Time Machine.

I logged in to my Mac with the account I wanted to be protected with the Yubico YubiKeys.

I ran the following command in terminal

mkdir –m0700 –p ~/.yubico

I double checked that my Yubico key(s) were set up for challenge response (above).

I inserted my Uubico key and ran this command

ykpamcfg -2

Feel free to read the “ykpamcfg” manual here. The yubico-pam source code is located here.

Output:

The contents of “/Users/simon/.yubico/challenge-#######” looked like (I replaced 232 random chars with #’s below). The filename ended with my keys serial number.

v2:########################################################################################################################################################################################################################################:10000:2

Next, I was supposed to copy the challenge output from ykpamcfg to /var/root/.yubico/challenge-[YUBIKEY SERIAL NUMBER] with this command..

sudo cp /var/root/.yubico/challenge-[YUBIKEY SERIAL NUMBER] /Users/[USERNAME]/.yubico

But I had this error.

No such file or directory

Weird as the source file existed?? macOS issues?

I Opened /Users/[USERNAME]/.yubico/challenge-[YUBIKEY SERIAL NUMBER] in the nano editor (sudo elevated process) and saved the file to /var/root/.yubico/challenge-[YUBIKEY SERIAL NUMBER].

I reopened my terminal and verified the contents of /var/root/.yubico/challenge-[YUBIKEY SERIAL NUMBER]. The file is now there.

Permissions on the file is “-rw——-“. Good.

I inserted my second backuP key and re-ran “ykpamcfg -2” and copied the file to “/Users/simon/.yubico”

I verified the file contents

sudo cd /var/root/.yubico/
ls -al

Output

Text Output:

> drwxr-xr-x 4 root wheel 128 9 Oct 09:50 .
> drwxr-x— 12 root wheel 384 9 Oct 09:39 ..
> -rw-r–r– 1 root wheel 244 9 Oct 09:50 challenge-#######
> -rw-r–r– 1 root wheel 244 9 Oct 09:42 challenge-#######

Snip from: https://www.yubico.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/yubico_YubiKeyMacLoginGuide_en.pdf

“Program at least two YubiKeys when implementing a requirement for authentication with a YubiKey on your Mac. If you configure only one YubiKey and something happens to the YubiKey, you must restore the Mac from a Time Machine backup that you created before editing the authorization file before you can log back in to your account. ”

Reading the guide regarding multiple accounts (setting up a Key for each login). I have 5 logins on my Mac but when this works I will disable the other accounts from logging in.

Enable the use of the Yubico key when the screensaver is deactivated on macOS

I opened a terminal and edited “/etc/pam.d/screensaver ” (I use the easier nano editor)

sudo nano /etc/pam.d/screensaver

I added this line

auth       required       /usr/local/lib/security/pam_yubico.so mode=challenge-response

auth[7 spaces]required[7 spaces]/usr/local/lib/security/pam_yubico.so mode=challenge-response

I saved the file ( [CTRL+O], [CTRL+X] ) and exited nano.

I tested my screensaver and no extra protection was provided (the screensaver just exited).

I rebooted, still no change?

I reinstalled the PAM module.

Silly me, I needed to enable the password on the screensaver to then activate the /etc/pam.d/screensaver entries.

I enabled the screensaver passwords

I am now prompted to enter my password and inset and tap my Yubico Key on screensaver exit (on both keys). Awesome.

Next, I need to enable this at macOS login.

Enable the use of the Yubico key at macOS Login

I edited /etc/pam.d/authorization file with nano in the terminal

sudo nano /etc/pam.d/authorization

I added the same line as was added to the file /etc/pam.d/screensaver

auth       required       /usr/local/lib/security/pam_yubico.so mode=challenge-response

auth[7 spaces]required[7 spaces]/usr/local/lib/security/pam_yubico.so mode=challenge-response

I saved the file ( [CTRL+O], [CTRL+X] ) and exited nano.

Now let’s log out and test this.

It’s working.

Excellent

Add Two Factor Authentication to 1Password

Here is a guide on using the Yubico YubiKey with 1Password. This directed me to https://support.1password.com/yubikey/

I downloaded the Yubico Authenticator app on macOS and installed it.

After I inserted my primary Key I received a “No Credentials Found”message.

I logged into https://my.1password.com/signin and clicked My Profile.

I clicked More Actions then Turn On Two-Factor Authentication

I added the generated QR code details to the Android Authenticator and macOS Yubico Authenticator app. At first, I could not scan the QR code in macOS (was Mojave blocking this?), I manually entered the details (after confirming them from the Android app QR code scan).

Details:

• Issuer: 1Password
• Account Name: my.1password.com
• Secret Key: ###################
• Time: 30
• Algorithm: SHA-1
• Period: 30
• Digits: 6

Now, 1Password web and the desktop app are asking for the 2-factor code (generated in the Yubico Authenticator app after I insert my YubioKey).

Nice

I logged off and I was not prompted for my Two Factor code?

Snip from: https://support.1password.com/two-factor-authentication/

“Your 1Password account is now protected by two-factor authentication. From now on, you’ll need to enter a six-digit authentication code from your authenticator app when you sign in to 1Password on a new device.”

I logged in to 1Password from Google Chrome on Android and indeed I was prompted for a two-factor auth code form the Yubico Authenticator app (with a KubiKey inserted).

Add Two Factor Authentication to Dropbox
I read https://www.yubico.com/works-with-yubikey/catalog/dropbox-personal/. Dropbox also has setup instructions here.

I logged into Dropbox and went to Settings then Security then clicked Add next to Security Keys

I started the Wizard, entered my Dropbox password, then inserted my YubiKey.

Name the Key

I added my Primary and Backup Key(s)

I logged out and back in and no Security Key prompt?

I am using Chrome and had cleared past browsers from the Dropbox list of web browsers at https://www.dropbox.com/account/security

I discovered that I need to set the primary authentication method to Use Mobile App (My Bad, it would be nice if Dropbox set this as default after I added the keys).

I added the Dropbox QR code to the Yuboico Authenticator app

I was asked to enter a 6 digit code from my Yubico Authenticator app to verify the working link. I inserted my YubiKey into my machine to show the code.

Now Dropbox is configured 🙂

Success

I now have to insert my primary key when logging into Dropbox

I need to find a way to copy my Authenticator credentials to my Backup Key from my Primary key

Add Two Factor Authentication to Twitter

I read https://www.yubico.com/works-with-yubikey/catalog/twitter/ (Setup Instructions)

1) Login to Twitter

2) Open your Settings and Look For Security

3) Click Start

4) Enter Your Password

5) Accept and enter any SMS codes if you set up SMS Two Factor codes via SMS

6) Click “Review your login verification methods”

7) Click “Setup Key”

8) Insert Your YubiKey and follow the prompts to activate it.

9) Now the key will be requoted to log in to Twitter

Testing Two Factor Login to Twitter

I logged out of and back into Twitter but the SMS Two Factor Authentication method was still active?

I tried to disable the SMS method in Twitter but two factor was disabled altogether and the registered key was deleted. I re-added my key 🙁

I solved this by choosing “Choose a different verification method” when logging in then choosing “Use your security key“, Twitter then accessed my YubiKey and further login attempts used the key instead of SMS 🙂 I could use an Authenticator code but they YubiKey touch method is quicker.

Done

It would be nice if Twitter allowed multiple keys to be used to log in?

Add Two Factor Authentication to Google, Google cloud, Gsuite etc

I read https://www.yubico.com/works-with-yubikey/catalog/google-accounts (Instructions https://myaccount.google.com/).

Adding two Factor authentication details to Google was not easily accessible at Google so I Googled (lol) this https://support.yubico.com/support/solutions/articles/15000006418-using-your-yubikey-with-google

I loaded: https://myaccount.google.com/signinoptions/two-step-verification/enroll-welcome

I clicked Get Start

I clicked Choose Another Option (not SMS Two factor)

Clicked Security Key

As prompted I inserted my key and allowed access to it.

I named the Key

I repeated the steps and added my 2nd key.

Done

I logged out my https://myaccount.google.com and logged back in and I was prompted to insert my YubiKey

Nice

I did try and login to my google GSuite account at https://admin.google.com but it did not prompt me to insert a key. I will do this next.

Add Two Factor Authentication to GSuite

I logged into the GSuite admin interface at https://admin.google.com/ I generated some backup codes in case I need them in the future.

I checked my main admin user account and I could see the 2 google security keys synced through from Google.

I then searched GSuite for “Two Factor” and loaded the “Enforcement” Page

I enabled “Turn On Enforcement Now”

I enabled “Only Security Keys”

I logged out and back into https://gsuite.google.com/ TWICE and no security key prompt.

Silly me: I forgot to click save at the bottom of the screen and it appears there is a 24-hour delay?

Add Two Factor Authentication to GMail

This is already done (above), GSuite email takes up to 24 hours to become active, GMail is instant.

Add Two Factor Authentication to Google Analytics

I can’t see an option to turn Two Factor Auth on in Google Analytics 🙂

I did send feedback to the Google Analytics team.

Add Two Factor Authentication to Google Adsense

I can’t see an option to turn Two Factor Auth on in Google Adsense either 🙂

I did send feedback to the Google AdSense team.

Add Two Factor Authentication to Github

I logged into Github, opened my Settings and clicked Security then Enable two-factor authentication

Click Setup using an app save the recovery codes.

Open the Yubico Authenticator app (ensure you can see the QR Code in GitHub)

In the Yubico Authenticator, App click File then Scan QR Code

The GitHub details should be added to the Authenticator

Two Factor via authenticator tokens is enabled and now I can see a Keys options,

I clicked Add next to security keys then Register New Device, I gave the key a name then clicked Add.

I added both keys then I Logged out and back in and two factor was enabled by YubiKey 🙂

Add Two Factor Authentication to Debian servers in the cloud (SSH)

Read Setup two-factor authenticator protection at login on Ubuntu or Debian

Add Two Factor Authentication to Ubuntu servers in the cloud (SSH)

Read Setup two-factor authenticator protection at login on Ubuntu or Debian

YubiKey Support

There are loads of Yubico support articles here: https://support.1password.com/yubikey/

Yubico Developer Info

A GitHub repository of source code is located here: https://github.com/Yubico

Other developer related pages here

• • • https://developers.yubico.com/FIDO2/
    • https://developers.yubico.com/OTP/
    • https://developers.yubico.com/U2F/
    • https://developers.yubico.com/OATH/
    • https://developers.yubico.com/PGP/
    • https://developers.yubico.com/PIV/
    • https://developers.yubico.com/YubiHSM2/
    • https://developers.yubico.com/Software_Projects/

Securing WordPress

Read this guide on Securing WordPress with 2FA (YubiKey insertion or Authenticator app).

I found a good WordPress plugin to handle 2FA logn methods.

I am prompted to insert my YubiKey after logging into WordPress.

Nice

Java Code to use the Yubico YubiKey in software (challenge mode)

todo: I will add this section soon.

Yubico has Java repository that contains a Java library with an accompanying demo server, as well as a JAAS module, to validate YubiKey OTP’s (One-Time Passwords).

https://developers.yubico.com/yubico-java-client/

PHP Code to use the Yubico YubiKey in software (challenge mode)

todo: I will add this section soon.

Yubico has PHP library ad source code but it has not been updated in 3 years. I cannot get this working on PHP 7.2.

https://github.com/Yubico/php-yubico

Using Yubico YubiKeys as 2fA with one-time Passwords.

The YubiKeys can be used to store and generate one time passwords.

Read more about 2fa here

• twofactorauth.org
• turnon2fa.com/tutorials

Here is a good plugin to tell you what sites use 2fa as you browse: https://2fanotifier.org

I have used my YubuKeys to store dozens of 2fa One time password son sites

e.g Namecheap

I enabled 2fa OTP (over phone/SMS 2fa) at Namecheap

Recovery info and backup

Always setup, and obtain backup access codes (or set alternate two-factor login methods) to software and know how you can disable YubiKey 2FA logins if needed.

Read more on YubiKey data backup policy here.

Copy Yubico Authenticator credentials to my Backup Key from my Primary Key

My Primary and Secondary YubiKeys have different Authenticator credentials (I need to sync them)

Set a YubKey Password (Yubico Authenticator App)

You can set a YubiKey Password so limit access to Two Factor Linked Accounts in the Yubico Authenticator. Nice.

• • 1. Open the Yubico Authenticator App
    2. Insert your YubiKey
    3. Open the File then Set Password Menu
    4. Click Set Password

Now when you insert the YubiKey you will be prompted for a password Before Two Factor tokens are displayed.

Find a YubiKey Device Quiz

Use this quiz to find the right YubiKey for you: https://www.yubico.com/quiz/

Final Warning

Do not attempt to activate Two Factor Authentication on a system unless you…

• A) Have backups of your data
• B) Have backup methods of getting into your account(s)

Murphy’s Law: “Anything that can go wrong will go wrong”

You never know when a Two Factor Authentication Key may die or an Authenticator app or a Mac/PC may stop working so always have a backup method just in case.

Issue(s)

Thunderbird email on Google Chrome (accessing GSuite) is not accepting the key.

It is prompting…

But it is not recognising the key (no matter how many times I insert or press the key)?

It appears Thunderbird 52 may not support keys yet, May have to wait until release 60.

I installed Thunderbird 63 (BETA) from https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/channel/

After I installed Thunderbird it asked for my Security Key, accepted it and asked for further permissions.

I can now read my email in Thunderbird with my YubiKey

Update: June 2019

1Password now allow you to setup 2FA (authenticator app or YuiKey leys (or both)) authentication on your 1Password login. Read the official post here.

Goto https://my.1password.com/profile/2fa to setup 2FA.

You can setup 2FA (authapp and or hardware keys)

You will be notified by email if a 2FA method is setup.

You will need to sign out and back into your apps web, Desktop and Mobile.

Web Signin

You will need to insert and press your hardwre key.

And enter your 2FA code

Mobile app login

I used my YubiCo Authentocator app to get the temporary OTP.

You can remove previous logged in devices from accessing your data or force them to reqire 2FA at next login

Nice

Links

YubiCo Device Comparison Chart: https://www.yubico.com/products/yubikey-hardware/compare-yubikeys/

Email Subscription form YubiCo: https://pages.yubico.com/email_subscription.html

Conclusion

Thunderbird issues (solved by installing a BETA).

Not all apps have the same method (some have Authenticator App only) and some have YubiKey Insert/Touch, some allow one key or multiple keys.

The only issue is my Huawei Mate 9 phone is a little flakey at reading NFC (fixed: I just have to tap for 5 seconds)

I have attached the YubiKeys to a dog chain’s and they live around my neck.

Version History

v1.1 Added authenticator/Namecheap 2fa info.
v1.0.1 YubiKey Backup Policy and comparison chart
v1.0.0 WordPress
v0.8.1 authenticator apps
v0.8.0 Draft: Debian/Ubuntu and many other changes
v0.7.0.1 Draft: Issue – Thunderbird Issue Solved
v0.7.0 Draft: Issue – Thunderbird Issue
v0.6.9 Draft: Protected GitHub
v0.6.9 Draft: Unable to Protect Google AdSense and Analytics
v0.6.8 Draft: Protected Google Gmail (https://gmail.com)
v0.6.7 Draft: Protected Google GSuite (https://gsuite.google.com/ and https://admin.google.com/)
v0.6.6 Draft: Protected Google (https://myaccount.google.com/)
v0.6.5 Draft: Protected Twitter
v0.6 Draft: Set a YubKey Password (Yubico Authenticator App)
v0.5 Draft: Sync Authenticator credentials?
v0.4 Draft: Protected Dropbox
v0.3 Draft: Protected 1Password
v0.2 Draft: Protected macOS Login
v0.1 Draft: Protected macOS Screensaver